This location has closed.
Jimmy’s Food Store

photography by Kevin Hunter Marple

Jimmy’s Food Store


  • Readers' Choice: Best Sandwich (2018)
  • Readers' Choice: Best Italian Food (2018)
  • Best Breakfasts (2016)
  • Readers' Choice: Best Sandwich Shop (2015, 2014, 2013, 2012, 2011, 2010)
  • Best Neighborhood Restaurants (2008)
  • Readers' Choice (2022)


Many think of Jimmy’s as simply a sandwich counter that’s home to a miraculous meatball sub. But it’s also a market stocked with fresh fruits and vegetables, cheeses, frozen lasagnas and pizza dough, dried pasta, olive oil, and aisles and aisles of wine.

Let this restaurant know you found them on D Magazine’s Online Directories.